The Sociological Study of Science and Religion in Context
Keywords:
science, religion, knowledge, secularization, sociologyAbstract
This paper reflects on some of the cross-disciplinary, historical and philosophical issues that are need to consider in order to conduct research into science and religion in their historical, social and cultural contexts. First, it is argued in favor of moving away from an assumption of implicit conflict between science and religion and towards a complexity thesis that allows us to be cognizant of the nuance of how these two concepts interact as part of individuals’ lived experience, or as social, group or cultural identities. Next, the need for a meta-reflexivity is pointed out to make aware the limitations and the assumptions of the disciplines of the social sciences or humanities that can distort the understanding of the public attitudes towards science and religion. Finally, the limitations of quantitative methods, that have dominated the social study of the relationships between science and religion are noted. The need for qualitative, more contextual models about the positions of individuals or groups within of the geopolitical, cultural and social contexts that lead scientific issues to act as an identity marker across a spectrum of religious, spiritual, non-religious and atheistic publics are also pointed out in this paper.Downloads
References
Barbour, I.G. (1990). Religion in an age of science: The Gifford lectures 1989–1991 (vol 1), London: SCM.
Barbour, I.G. (1997). Religion and science: Historical and contemporary issues, San Francisco: Harper San Francisco.
Bauer, M.W., Allum, N. y Miller, S. (2007). What can we learn from 25 years of PUS survey research? Liberating and expanding the agenda’, Public Understanding of Science, 16(1): 79–95.
Brooke, J.H. (1991). Science and religion: Some historical perspectives, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Cantor, G. y Kenny, C. (2001). Barbour’s fourfold way: problems with his taxonomy of science–religion relationships, Zygon; Journal of Religion and Science, 36(4): 765–81.
Carlisle, J. et al. (2019). "Muslim Perceptions of Biological Evolution: A Critical Review of Quantitative and Qualitative Research". En Jones, S. H; Kaden, T. y Catto, R. (ed.). Science, Belief and Society: International Perspectives on Religion, Non-Religion and the Public Understanding of Science. Bristiol: . Bristol University Press.
Coyne, J. (2015). Faith vs. fact: Why science and religion are incompatible, New York: Penguin Random House LLC.
Draper, J.W. (1874). History of the conflict between religion and science, New York, NY, and London: D. Appleton and Company.
Durkheim, E. (2001 [1912]). Elementary forms of the religious life, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Ecklund, E.H. y Scheitle, C.P. (2018). Religion vs. science: What religious people really think, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Elsdon-Baker, F. (2015). Creating creationists: the influence of "issues framing" on our understanding of public perceptions of clash narratives between evolutionary science and belief , Public Understanding of Science, 24(4): 422–39.
Elsdon-Baker, F. (2017, 5 de septiembre). Questioning evolution is neither science denial nor the preserve of creationists, The Guardian.
Elsdon-Baker, F. (2018). "Re-examining "creationist" monsters in the uncharted waters of the social study of science and religion". En B. Nerlich, S. Hartley, S. Raman y A. Smith (eds). Science and the politics of openness: Here be monsters (258–77), Manchester: Manchester University Press.
Elsdon-Baker, F. (en prensa). "Creating hardline "secular" evolutionists: the influence of question design on our understanding of public perceptions of clash narratives between evolutionary science and belief". En F. Elsdon-Baker and B. Lightman (eds). Science and religion: Exploring the spectrum, Pittsburgh: University of Pittsburgh Press.
Evans, J. (2018). Morals not knowledge: Recasting the contemporary U.S. conflict between religion and science, Berkeley: University of California Press.
Evans, J.H. y Evans, M.S. (2008). Religion and science: beyond the epistemological conflict narrative, Annual Review of Sociology, 34: 87–105.
Fleck, L. (1935). The genesis and development of a scientific fact, Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Gould, S.J. (1999). Rock of ages: Science and religion in the fullness of life, New York: Penguin Random House LLC.
Harrison, P. (2015). The territories of science and religion, Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Hill, J.P. (2014). Rejecting evolution: the role of religion, education, and social networks, Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion, 53(3): 575–94.
Hill, J.P. (2019). "Survey-based Research on Science and Religion: A Review and Critique". En Jones, S. H; Kaden, T. y Catto, R. (ed.). Science, Belief and Society: International Perspectives on Religion, Non-Religion and the Public Understanding of Science. Bristiol: . Bristol University Press.
Jones, S. H; Kaden, T. y Catto, R. (ed.) (2019). Science, Belief and Society: International Perspectives on Religion, Non-Religion and the Public Understanding of Science. Bristiol: . Bristol University Press.
Jones, S., Catto, R., Kaden, T. y Elsdon-Baker, F. (2019). "That is how Muslims are required to view the world": race, culture and belief in non-Muslims’ descriptions of Islam and science, The Sociological Review, 67(1): 161–77.
Kaden, T. et al. (2019). "Language, Labels and Lived Identity in Debates about Science, Religion and Belief" En Jones, S. H; Kaden, T. y Catto, R. (ed.). Science, Belief and Society: International Perspectives on Religion, Non-Religion and the Public Understanding of Science. Bristiol: . Bristol University Press.
Kind, S. (2019). "Avoiding the ‘Anti-intellectual Abyss’: How Secular Humanists in Sweden try to Define the Boundaries between Science, Religion, Pseudoscience and Postmodernism". En Jones, S. H; Kaden, T. y Catto, R. (ed.). Science, Belief and Society: International Perspectives on Religion, Non-Religion and the Public Understanding of Science. Bristiol: . Bristol University Press.
Kuhn, T. (1962). The structure of scientific revolutions, Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Lightman, B., Nickerson, S. y Tajbakhsh, P. (en prensa). "From conflict to complexity: historians and 19th century public perceptions of science and religion". En F. Elsdon-Baker y B. Lightman (eds). Science and religion: Exploring the spectrum, Pittsburgh: University of Pittsburgh Press.
Marx, K. (1970 [1843]), "Critique of Hegel’s philosophy of right". En J. O’Malley (de). Marx: Early political writings, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Miller, J.D. (1983). Scientific literacy: a conceptual and empirical review, Daedalus, 112(2): 29–48.
Miller, J.D. (2010). "The conceptualisation and measurement of civic scientific literacy for the twenty-first century". En J. Meinwald y J.G. Hildebrand (eds). Science and the educated American: A core component of liberal education (241–55), Cambridge: American Academy of Arts and Sciences.
Miller, S. (2001). Public understanding of science at the crossroads,Public Understanding of Science, 10(1): 115–20.
Noy, S. y O’Brien, T.L. (2018). An intersectional analysis of perspectives on science and religion in the United States, The Sociological Quarterly, 59(1): 40–61.
Numbers, R. (ed.) (2009). Galileo goes to jail and other myths about science and religion, Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Reid, L. (2019). "Researching Clergy Attitudes towards Science: A Reflective Account of Key Methodological Challenges". En Jones, S. H; Kaden, T. y Catto, R. (ed.). Science, Belief and Society: International Perspectives on Religion, Non-Religion and the Public Understanding of Science. Bristiol: . Bristol University Press.
Sharp, S. y Leicht, C. (en prensa). "Beyond belief systems: promoting a social identity approach to the study of science and religion". En F. Elsdon-Baker and B. Lightman (eds). Science and religion: Exploring the spectrum, Pittsburgh: University of Pittsburgh Press.
Sturgis, P. y Allum, N. (2004). Science in society: re-evaluating the deficit model of public attitudes, Public Understanding of Science, 13(1): 55–74.
Unsworth, A. (2019). "Discourses on Science and Islam: A View from Britain". En Jones, Stephen H; Kaden, Tom y Catto, Rebecca (ed.) (2019) Science, Belief and Society: International Perspectives on Religion, Non-Religion and the Public Understanding of Science (pp. 3–24). Bristol University Press.
Weber, M. (2002 [1905]). The protestant ethic and the spirit of capitalism, New York: Penguin.
White, A.D. (2009 [1896]). A history of the warfare of science with theology in Christendom, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
